Confronting Violence at Church
Maryville shooting, Texas murder underscore need for preparation.

The current issue of Leadership Journal revisits the fatal shooting of Pastor Fred Winters as he preached one Sunday morning at First Baptist Church in Maryville, Illinois. The piece recounts–in chilling detail–his final moments on March 8, 2009, as the suspect approached the pulpit while hiding a .45 caliber Glock pistol underneath a church bulletin:

Pastor Fred Winters was in the early moments of his sermon. He looked at the man standing in the aisle and asked, "May I help you?"
At that moment the stranger removed a church bulletin covering the gun and began shooting. The first shot hit Pastor Winters's Bible, shredding it into what people perceived as confetti. The reality of what was happening didn't register with anyone yet, in fact some later commented they thought it was a drama sketch.
Pastor Winters yelled, "It's real, this is real!" and moved toward the side of the stage.
The second and third shots each missed Pastor Winters. He jumped off the stage toward the gunman and grabbed the gun. It was there the fourth and final shot hit the pastor in the chest, piercing his heart and killing him."

The article goes on to share how the church has worked to heal from the trauma in the two years since, including interviews with the church's ministers of worship and pastoral care, as well as Winters' wife. While the suspect remains in custody awaiting trial, one disturbing fact remains:

To this day, there is no understanding of why the shooter picked this church on this day. He had no prior connection with First Baptist. No motive has been discovered. It was a random act of violence.

Considering the number of Christian churches in the country (most estimates usually put the figure at about 300,000) and the number of services that take place every week at those churches, random acts of violence like this one are a rarity. These incidents serve as reminders that, though rare, church leaders still must work to prevent them–or know what to do if a potential situation begins to unfold.

Sadly, another such reminder arose earlier this month.

On March 3, police say two men entered the offices of NorthPointe Baptist Church in Arlington, Texas, where Pastor Clint Dobson and his office assistant worked.

They began to rob Dobson and his assistant–and then did the unthinkable.

According to a police report, the suspects murdered Dobson, 29, by suffocating him with a plastic bag. They also attacked his assistant, seriously injuring her.

The suspects were arrested a few days later, thanks to a tip from two women who said they heard the men "laughing and making inappropriate comments" while watching news reports of the pastor's death, according to a report by KTVT, the local CBS television affiliate in Dallas-Fort Worth.

In both the Maryville and Arlington stories, we see the ongoing challenges churches face when it comes to safety and security. Openness and accessibility, essential qualities for any church that wants to reach out, can be used by individuals who wish to do harm. The thought of pre-screening people before they attend a worship service seems absurd; many churches offer benevolence–frequently involving food and money–throughout the week as people in need show up at their offices looking for help.

What can be done? A pastor and office assistant I recently spoke with say they may consider installing security camera systems at their respective church offices as a way to keep their building secure throughout the week (and create a possible deterrent by showing a would-be attacker that their face will be recorded before they enter).

What other steps are worth taking? For help on this question, our sister site,, offers the following electronic training resources for local churches:

* Confronting Gun Violence at Church

* Protecting Your Church From Crime and Violence

* Dealing with Dangerous People

How is your church addressing this question?

This content is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is published with the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, or other professional service. If legal advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional person should be sought. "From a Declaration of Principles jointly adopted by a Committee of the American Bar Association and a Committee of Publishers and Associations."


Displaying 1–5 of 5 comments


August 17, 2011  11:40am

Bill, For some reason, I only now came across your comment to our March 2011 blog post regarding church safety and security. I can't recall whether anyone (including myself) responded to your request to receive regular updates on this topics. In case we didn't, let me point you to three free e-newsletters that regularly cover these topics: • Church Safety: • Church Law & Tax Update: • Church Management Update: I pray these are helpful. Best, Matt

Report Abuse

Mark Van Holt

June 11, 2011  2:29pm

Churches across our great country represent what is most commonly referred to as a "soft target." Similar in nature to a public school, it is highly unlikely that we will ever see a Houses of Worship taking a hardened approach to securing their facility and protecting their staff and congregates. The only option for most churches is to have a security plan in place, and, if possible "volunteers" whether they be off-duty police officers or members with a security (military) background to simply take on a more active role in security. Similar to Mrs. Terry Kirkpatrick who posted on April 6th, I too volunteer my time and effort in securing our church. There's a great deal that goes on behind the scenes when it comes to protecting the thousands who visit us each week.

Report Abuse

Bill Guyer

April 06, 2011  1:59pm

I am glad a friend of mine sent this link to me. I am the Director of Security for a Large Church in Newbury Park California. I would like o receive updates. Thank You

Report Abuse

Mrs. Terry Kirkpatrick

April 06, 2011  1:59pm

Unfortunately, this kind of thing happens all too often. We simply keep our doors locked. There is a policy for benevolence - you must have an appointment. We do not answer the door if it is someone we don't recognize. I am usually here alone, so leaving the door unlocked is not an option. Our monthly benevolence is distributing food vouchers to the local food bank. There is a policy for benevolence - you must have an appointment. Unless the pastor is in the building ( we are small, and he has calls to make, so he is in and out), those who show up at the door have to be told to make an appointment and come back. I believe that this has saved us from would-be attacks a few times. If they genuinely need the help, they will do as we ask. If they're not genuine, they don't come back. I am a devout CHICKEN! But better a live chicken than a dead duck!

Report Abuse


March 23, 2011  3:39pm

The public safety director for DeKalb County, Georgia, says his municipality may require all new businesses to install security cameras. He shared this during a meeting with a church and community shortly after a man was arrested for raping a woman in February at a church office:

Report Abuse
Recent Posts
Subscribe to Church, Law & Tax
Protecting Your Church from Crime and Violence

Protecting Your Church from Crime and Violence

Assess the security of your church and learn how to prevent crime.
Waivers and Releases

Waivers and Releases

10 descriptions and forms to help you assemble waivers and releases.