Jump directly to the content

Housing Allowance Challenge Dismissed

Plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed their challenge

In the July/August 2011 edition of Church Law & Tax Report, we provided an update on a lawsuit brought by the Freedom from Religion Foundation ("FFRF") and several other plaintiffs in a federal district court in California challenging the constitutionality of the parsonage exclusion and housing allowance. We opined that this challenge may have been dealt a fatal blow as a result of a recent United States Supreme Court case. The high court ruled (5-4) that a group of Arizona taxpayers lacked "standing" to challenge the constitutionality of a state law that gave tax credits for contributions to "school tuition organizations" (STOs) that provided scholarships to students attending private schools, including religious schools. It noted that the courts have consistently ruled that standing cannot be based on a plaintiff's status as a federal taxpayer because the "injury" is too remote or speculative.

The Court acknowledged a limited exception to taxpayer standing in cases challenging legislation on the basis of the First Amendment's nonestablishment of religion clause. Taxpayers have standing in such cases to challenge direct transfers of tax revenue to religious organizations since "the taxpayer's allegation in such cases would be that his tax money is being extracted and spent in violation of specifi c constitutional protections against such abuses of legislative power." But the Court concluded that there is a difference between direct transfers of tax revenues to religious organizations, and credits and deductions, and it limited taxpayer standing to the former context. This ruling left no doubt that the plaintiffs challenging the housing allowance lacked standing since a tax exclusion, rather than a direct transfer of tax revenue to religion, was involved. As a result, the plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed their challenge on June 17, 2011.

Article Preview

This article is currently available to ChurchLawAndTax.com subscribers only. To continue reading:

LoginorSubscribe

Related Resources

See All
from our store
20 Finance Questions Churches Ask eBook

20 Finance Questions Churches Ask eBook

Richard Hammar shares his answers to 20 of the most widely asked and relevant tax and finance questions for church leaders.
2014 Church & Clergy Tax Guide

2014 Church & Clergy Tax Guide

Get a comprehensive understanding of tax laws as they relate to pastors and churches.
Preventing Top Tax Pitfalls

Preventing Top Tax Pitfalls

Learn the background you need on tax laws to know what questions to ask.
Avoiding Church Lawsuits

Avoiding Church Lawsuits

Create proactive procedures to avoid common reasons why churches most often go to court.
browse
Follow us:Church Law & Tax on FacebookChurch Law & Tax on TwitterChurch Law & Tax RSS FeedsChurch Law & Tax on Youtube