Employment Dispute Ruling Reinforces Church Decisions about Hiring and Firing
Employment Dispute Ruling Reinforces Church Decisions about Hiring and Firing
Seventh Circuit: Churches, not courts, should determine ministerial nature of roles.

The US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, headquartered in Chicago, decided an important case last week regarding the ministerial exception to employment discrimination laws. The answers to the questions before the court in this case are important ones. The ministerial exception to employment discrimination claims gives churches the right to hire and fire and make employment decisions for any reason without being subject to Title VII (and other employment discrimination laws).

The case

The case involved a lawsuit brought by Stanislaw Sterlinski, who claimed he was fired from his position as a church organist because of his Polish heritage. Sterlinski once was the church’s director of music, but was demoted to the job of organist and later fired.

The Seventh Circuit recognized Sterlinski’s role as music director meant he was a “minister” for purposes of the ministerial exception to Title VII and therefore could have been fired for any reason by the church. But the questions the court wrestled with focused on whether Sterlinski could be considered a “minister” after he was demoted to the position of organist and, more importantly, who ultimately decides whether one’s role is ministerial—the employing church or a court.

Sterlinski argued that his job was simply to play notes assigned to him and therefore his role was not religious. The church argued that music was an integral part of its services and so the organist position was religious.

Log In For Full Access

Interested in becoming a member? Learn more.

Posted:
August 13, 2019
View All
from our store
12 Law & Tax Guidelines for New Ministers

12 Law & Tax Guidelines for New Ministers

Essential knowledge to ensure legal and financial clarity and integrity in ministry.
Your Guide To Employee Handbooks

Your Guide To Employee Handbooks

If updated regularly, an employee handbook can offer valuable legal protection against civil court claims made by disgruntled staff members.
Understanding Labor Laws

Understanding Labor Laws

Regulations that pertain to hiring, firing, paying, disciplining, and supervising ministry employees.
Understanding Pastoral Liability

Understanding Pastoral Liability

Know the situations in which a pastor is personally liable for wrongdoing.

ChurchSalary

ChurchSalary

Experience a whole new way to set compensation. Eliminate the guesswork – get access to detailed compensation reports in just minutes.